|
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] iSCSI: error recovery striation for rev08 (Was: iSCSI - open issues - no discussion - recovery levels)>- on the recovery there is consesus that it is a good idea; there is no >consensus on how many layers to enforce (I think that 2 - all or nothing is >a good choice). I am sure Julian is trying to kick off a discussion here, after collaborating with me on the London proposals :-) Seriously, Julian and I were both hoping for more comments before rev08 in this area - which I haven't seen too many of. Let me state for the record (as I already said in London) that all-or-nothing is not to my favor - IMHO, that erects a too steep barrier between the two levels. I however can see the case for considering decreasing the number of levels. Allow me sometime for cogitation on this once rev08 is published. I hope to post an alternative scheme of striation by the end of next week for WG consideration. For rev08, current plan is to capture what was presented in London, but state clearly that this area is still under debate. Thanks. -- Mallikarjun Mallikarjun Chadalapaka Networked Storage Architecture Network Storage Solutions Organization MS 5668 Hewlett-Packard, Roseville. cbm@rose.hp.com >Dear colleagues, > >Considering that the next plugfest is getting close and we would like to >have >version 08 ready for it. > >We have two open items that got little attention on the list up to now: > >- taking out the markers and inserting a reference to an external framing >draft (what is mandatory, what is optional etc.) >- recovery the recovery levels proposal > >The status with both is as follows: > >- on the framing there is consensus that it is a good idea; there is no >consensus on what is MUST, SHOULD etc. >- on the recovery there is consesus that it is a good idea; there is no >consensus on how many layers to enforce (I think that 2 - all or nothing is >a good choice). > >Regards, >Julo > > >
Home Last updated: Tue Sep 04 12:17:10 2001 6328 messages in chronological order |