|
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] FCIP: Minutes of 10/17 FCIP Authors teleconferenceMinutes from last week's FCIP author's call. Elizabeth -----Original Message----- Minutes of FCIP Authors teleconference 10/17/01 1. Security Bob raised the issue that compliance requirements are made in both the FCIP draft as well as the security framework draft, although the security draft is intended to be an informational RFC. Not clear what happens if the two start to get out of sync. In addition, requirements on the same function in different drafts is not desirable. Is it even legal to put compliance requirements (MUST, etc) in a non-standards-track RFC? Issue also applies to iSCSI and iFCP. Bob to send note on issue to IPS reflector. 2. NAPT Solution documented by Ralph was discussed. Two issues were brought up: how to address the ships-in-the-night behavior when two TCP connect requests between 2 FCIP Entities cross each other, and how to make one end of the FCIP Link aware of who is at the other hand in terms of its WWN+FCIP-identifier identity. Larry suggested a bi-directional Short Frame exchange instead of the current proposed unidirectional one, allowing each end to learn about the other, to solve the latter. Anil believes this may help to address the ships-in-the-night problem. Bob feels that this is better solved at a lower layer, and that bidirectional SF exchange could introduce problems. Larry as well as Bob to send out mail detailing the incremental changes and potential issues, respectively. Another area of discussion was the need for more than one FCIP Link between two FCIP Entities. Some discussion around why this should be allowed for FCIP, just as it is allowed for FC. Milan and Bob feel that there is a need to accomodate this behavior (while also allowing a single link with multiple TCP connections). Ralph to add front matter to clarify context of solution in the presence of NAPT gateways in the next draft. Further discussion of solution and choices by email, final solution to be agreed by next week. Attendees: Ralph Weber Jim Nelson Vi Chau Milan Merhar Anil Rijhsinghani Raj Bhagwat Dave Peterson Elizabeth Rodriguez Bob Snively Bill Creek Don Fraser Venkat Rangan Larry Lamers Andy Helland
Home Last updated: Fri Nov 16 03:17:33 2001 7828 messages in chronological order |