SORT BY:

LIST ORDER
THREAD
AUTHOR
SUBJECT


SEARCH

IPS HOME


    [Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

    Re: FCIP: Comment 120



    Mallikarjun,
    
    > >... the "FC/FCIP Entity Identifier" is unique only within the scope 
    > >of the given FC Entity's WWN. ... the model allows multiple FCIP 
    > >Entities to be associated with the FC Fabric Entity WWN.
    >
    > If that is so, please add an architectural model diagram (similar to
    > Figure 3, or perhaps convert Figure 3 into) which clearly shows this
    > 1-to-n association.
    >
    > This is the only hint in the document (at least that I found) which
    > suggests the stated possibility.  Figure 3 with 1-to-1 association almost
    > seemed like the architectural model, but on careful reading, is only
    > an example.
    
    The fact that the "FC/FCIP Entity Identifier" is unique only within
    the scope of a given FC Entity's WWN seems to be clearly stated in the
    definition of the field:
    
      "The Source FC/FCIP Entity Identifier field SHALL contain a unique 
      identifier for the FC Entity FCIP Entity pair that generates (as opposed 
      to echoes) the Special Frame. The value is assigned by the FC Fabric 
      entity whose world wide name appears in the Source FC Fabric Entity World 
      Wide Name field.
    
      "Note: The combination of the Source FC Entity World Wide Name and Source 
      FCIP Entity Identifier fields uniquely identifies every FC Entity FCIP 
      Entity pair in the IP Network."
    
    The requested figure relies on Fibre Channel concepts and thus appears
    in a T11 document, FC-BB-2, ftp://ftp.t11.org/t11/pub/fc/bb-2/02-030v1.pdf.
    See Figure 23 on PDF page 87, or Figure 26 on PDF page 94.
    
    Thanks.
    
    .Ralph
    
    "Mallikarjun C." wrote:
    
    >
    > Ralph,
    >
    > > http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-ietf-ips-fcip-wglc-01.pdf
    > ....
    > > Please review these comments resolutions to ensure that
    > > the desired changes are described.
    >
    > Sorry for the delayed review, I have additional comments on wglc-01
    > for Comment 120.
    >
    > Regards.
    > --
    > Mallikarjun
    >
    > Mallikarjun Chadalapaka
    > Networked Storage Architecture
    > Network Storage Solutions Organization
    > Hewlett-Packard MS 5668
    > Roseville CA 95747
    > cbm@rose.hp.com
    >
    > >Comment 120
    > >> 8. The FCIP Special Frame
    > >......
    > >> Note: The combination of the Source FC Entity World Wide Name and
    > >> Source FCIP Entity Identifier fields uniquely identifies every FC
    > >> Entity FCIP Entity pair in the IP Network.
    > >....
    > >- Also I take it that the "FC/FCIP Entity Identifier" is unique only
    > >within the scope of the given FC Entity's WWN. So, does the model
    > >allow multiple FCIP Entities to be associated with the FC Fabric
    > >Entity WWN?
    > >....
    > >Response to the second bullet: Yes, the "FC/FCIP Entity Identifier"
    > >is unique only within the scope of the given FC Entity's WWN. Yes,
    > >the model allows multiple FCIP Entities to be associated with the FC
    > >Fabric Entity WWN.
    > >
    >
    > If that is so, please add an architectural model diagram (similar to
    > Figure 3, or perhaps convert Figure 3 into) which clearly shows this
    > 1-to-n association.
    >
    > This is the only hint in the document (at least that I found) which
    > suggests the stated possibility.  Figure 3 with 1-to-1 association almost
    > seemed like the architectural model, but on careful reading, is only
    > an example.
    
    


Home

Last updated: Mon May 06 14:18:30 2002
9983 messages in chronological order