Re: FC Mgmt mib

[Keith McCloghrie <kzm@cisco.com>]

Charissa,

Sorry for the delay, but I have spoken with Arvind and he agrees
that "encapsulates FC frames within another protocol" is a wide
enough scope to cover his device, and thus, you're right that no
change is needed for the FcUnitFunction TC.  

Further, the two objects within the current fcmEPortTable (i.e.,
fcmEPortClassFCredit and fcmEPortClassFDataFieldSize) can both be
applied to Arvind's device.  Now, you comment that fcmEPortClassFCredit
applies to B_Ports, and I'm confident that fcmEPortClassFDataFieldSize
does also.  Thus, the fcmEPortTable actually applies to E_Ports and
B_Ports.  So, rather than have separate tables for B_Ports and E_Ports,
with the same objects defined in both (i.e., a duplication), I'd like
to use the existing table for both types.  All that is required is to
change the name to, say, the fcmInterSwitchPortTable (which is roughly
what you suggested in your previous message), and update its definition
to say it applies to E_Ports, B_Ports and any other type of port which
interfaces to an inter-switch link.

If you agree, I'll go ahead and update the MIB.

Keith.


> Keith,
> 
> > 
> > 3. A new table for 'tunnel' ports
> > 
> > - I'd rather not add a new table unless it's absolutely necessary.
> >   How about I just broaden the scope of the fcmEPortTable so that
> >   it applies not only to E_Ports but also to 'tunnel' ports ??
> >
> 
> > The MIB will also need a new group for devices supporting 'tunnel'
> > functionality, which will contain just fcmEPortClassFCredit
> > and fcmEPortClassFDataFieldSize, right ??
> 
> For FC over IP a port can be either a B_port or an E_port. A B_port supports
> Class F frames and thus could at least use the Class F BB_Credit object that
> you specified in fcmEPortTable. 
> 
> The MIB defines the FcUnitFunction type of 'bridge' as "encapsulates FC
> frames within another protocol". Doesn't this imply "tunneling"? 
> 
> Since a B_port is transparent to the Fabric, just providing a table for
> B_Ports may provide a solution for other devices/ports that are transparent
> to the Fabric and need an object for BB_Credit.
> 
> Thanks,
> Charissa
>