Nandakumar,
There are no
restrictions on the amount of immediate data sent other than that it must be
less than MaxRecvDataSegmentLength and less than FirstBurstSize. So in the
conditions you have chosen, the initiator could send any amount of ImmediateData
from 4 Bytes to 8 KB. Doing so should not cause an error at the
target.
The purpose of
allowing an implicit InitialR2T is to gain efficiency by letting data start
flowing without having to wait a round-trip delay for an R2T. Gaining this
efficiency requires that the target know how much unsolicited data will be sent
when it receives the SCSI Command PDU so that it can immediately send the first
explicit R2T. The rule on sending the full FirstBurstSize (or all the data) when
unsolicited data is sent in Data-out PDUs achieves this. When the target sees
the SCSI Command PDU with the F bit set to 0, it knows that the first data it
needs to request with an R2T starts after FirstBurstSize
bytes.
When the SCSI
Command PDU has an F bit set to 1, then the target knows that DataSegmentLength
is the amound of unsolicited data being sent and it can construct its first R2T.
Therefore there is no reason to restrict the amount of unsolicited data
sent when only immediate data is sent (other than that it not exceed the
maximums).
That is what is
reflected in the rules.
Pat
Hi,
I have been following the discussion on this
thread.
I still have certain doubts regarding
the
conditions I specified in my original
mail.
The conditions are :
FirstBurstSize = 64KB
EDTL = 100KB ( EDTL >
FirstBurstSize)
MaxRecvDataSegmentLength = 8KB
ImmediateData = Yes
InitialR2T = Yes
In the above case the initiator cannot send
unsolicited Data-out PDUs.
Here unsolicited data(ImmediateData) < FirstBurstSize.
Will the target report any error in this case?
The modified
text for Section 9.4.6.2 only refers to the cases
where unsolicited Data-outs can be sent.
Please clarify if I am missing something very
obvious.
Thanks,
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Friday, June 21, 2002 11:41
AM
Subject: RE: iSCSI: FirstBurstSize and
unsolicited data
Eddy,
I
assume you meant EDTL not DSL and then the answer is yes and I again forgot to
subtract the immediate. A better formulation would be:
The target reports the "Incorrect
amount of data" condition if dur-ing data output the total data length to
output is greater than First-BurstSize and the initiator sent unsolicited
non-immediate data but the total amount of unsolicited data is different than
FirstBurst-Size. The target reports the same error when the amount of data
sent as a reply to an R2T does not match the amount requested.
Julo
| "Eddy Quicksall"
<Eddy@Quicksall.com>
06/21/2002 12:22 AM Please respond to "Eddy Quicksall"
| To:
Julian Satran/Haifa/IBM@IBMIL cc:
Subject: RE: iSCSI:
FirstBurstSize and unsolicited data
|
Isn't this saying that if DSL > FirstBurstSize, it would be
incorrect to send non-immediate unsolicited which is not equal to
FirstBurstSize?
The target reports the "Incorrect amount
of data" condition if dur-ing data output the total data length to output is
greater than First-BurstSize, but the initiator sent an amount different than
FirstBurstSize of unsolicited non-immediate data or the amount of data sent as
a reply to an R2T does not match the amount requested. Eddy
|