SORT BY:

LIST ORDER
THREAD
AUTHOR
SUBJECT


SEARCH

IPS HOME


    [Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

    Question on iSCSI security



    
    I am not up to speed on security and IPSec, so
    there is probably a simple answer to this.  I 
    would be curious to know what it is.
    
    
    Scenario:
    
    A is an unwitting initiator, B is a malicious
    target, and C is a victim target.
    
    A attempts to log into B using IPSec.  B establishes
    IPSec SA with C.  B is honest to IKE about its identity.
    After establishing SA, B attempts to log into C, but
    lies to the iSCSI layer and claims to be A.
    B uses classic man-in-the-middle technique to get
    A to respond to C's login challenge.  If this
    works, then B has successfully logged into C
    as A.
    
    There are a number of similar scenarios with the
    common thread that the attacker is truthful about
    his identity to the IPSec layer, but lies about
    his identity to the iSCSI layer.
    
    These attacks are easily defeated if the iSCSI
    layer cross checks remote end's identity with the 
    IPSec layer.  But it is not clear how this is done
    and whether it will be done or is required to 
    be done.
    
    If the IPSec layer verifies that the IP address
    INSIDE the tunnel really belongs to B, and iSCSI
    verifies that the IP address it sees really belongs
    to A, and the data consulted for the verification
    is secure, then one of these checks should fail,
    but this seems like a stretch.
    
    But perhaps I am missing something simple.
    
    


Home

Last updated: Thu Jun 12 17:19:24 2003
12634 messages in chronological order