RE: iSCSI NDT: Nameprep additions

["Jim Hafner" <hafner@almaden.ibm.com>]

Bob,

The short answer to this is not an extraordinarily strong argument,
however..., it was felt that these names should follow many of the rules of
domain names.  It was also felt that in many cases, the names might be
embedded in URLs (and the like).  Also, since one of the naming conventions
is derived from domain names, there didn't seem a strong reason to allow
for any extra characters.  So, the simpler the allowed set of
non-alpha-numeric characters (punctuation, whitespace, etc). the easier to
process, embed, extend, etc.

On the other hand, doesn't an "underscore" accomplish much of what a
"white-space" character does for readability?

Jim Hafner


Robert Snively <rsnively@Brocade.COM>@ece.cmu.edu on 08/20/2001 12:27:24 pm

Sent by:  owner-ips@ece.cmu.edu


To:   "'Mark Bakke'" <mbakke@cisco.com>, Kaladhar
      Voruganti/Almaden/IBM@IBMUS, IPS <ips@ece.cmu.edu>
cc:
Subject:  RE: iSCSI NDT: Nameprep additions



Mark,

Why did we want to prohibit a properly normalized
white-space character?  I have
always felt that spaces are useful supplements to readability,
especially for symbolic character sets.

Bob

-----Original Message-----
From: Mark Bakke [mailto:mbakke@cisco.com]
Sent: Thursday, August 16, 2001 2:20 PM
To: Kaladhar Voruganti; IPS
Subject: iSCSI NDT: Nameprep additions



Kaladhar-

Here are some modifications to make to the NDT doc to
add nameprep.  For now, these changes will assume that
nameprep will become an RFC before we do; if this is
a problem, we will do some more cut-and-paste later.

--
Mark


Replace:

    3. iSCSI names must be transcribable by humans.  iSCSI names should
       be kept as simple as possible, and should not use more than a
       few special characters.  They must also be case-insensitive, and
       cannot include white space.

With:

    3. iSCSI names must be transcribable by humans.  iSCSI names should
       be kept as simple as possible, and should not use more than a
       few special characters.  They must provide for the use of
       international character sets, and must not allow the use of
       different names that would be identical except for their case.
       Whitespace characters must not be allowed.

Replace:

   The iSCSI Name may be displayed by user interfaces, but is generally
   uninterpreted and used as an opaque, case-sensitive string for
   comparison with other iSCSI Name values.

With:

   The iSCSI Name may be displayed by user interfaces, but is generally
   uninterpreted and used as an opaque string for comparison with other
   iSCSI Name values.

Replace:


   An iSCSI name can be any Unicode character string with the following
   properties:

    - it is in Normalization Form C (see Unicode Standard Annex #15,
       "Unicode Normalization Forms" at
       http://www.unicode.org/unicode/reports/15)

    - it contains only the ASCII dash character ('-'=U+002d) or the
    ASCII dot character ('.'=U+002e) or is in one of the following
    Unicode General Categories:

             a) Lu (Letter, Uppercase)
             b) Ll (Letter, Lowercase)
             c) Lt (Letter, Titlecase)
             d) Lm (Letter, Modifier)
             e) Lo (Letter, Other)
             f) Nd (Number, Decimal Digit)
             g) Nl (Number, Letter)

             h) No (Number, Other)

    - when encoded in UTF-8, it is no more than 255 bytes

   In particular, white space, punctuation (except as noted), marks and
   symbols are not allowed.



With:

   An iSCSI name can be any Unicode character string with the following
   properties:

    - it is in Normalization Form C (see Unicode Standard Annex #15,
       "Unicode Normalization Forms" at
       http://www.unicode.org/unicode/reports/15)

    - it contains only the following types of characters:

         - ASCII dash character ('-'=U+002d)
         - ASCII dot character ('.'=U+002e)
         - Any character allowed by the output of the nameprep
           process

    - when encoded in UTF-8, it is no more than 255 bytes

   The output of the nameprep process is described in [NAMEPREP].  Nameprep
   is a method designed by the Internationalized Domain Name (IDN) working
   group to translate human-typed strings into a format that can be
compared
   as opaque strings, and does not include punctuation, spacing, dicritical
   marks, or other characters that could get in the way of
transcribability.
   It also converts everything into its equivalent of lower case.

   Note that in most cases, the nameprep process does not need to be
   implemented:

   - If the names are just generated using lower-case (in any
     character set) plus digits, no normalization is required.

   - If the names are generated from some other all-ASCII string,
     tolower() normalizes and isalnum() verifies.

   - If the names are generated from more general, internationalized
     text, either the equivalent of tolower() and isalnum() appropriate
     to the character set may be used, or the full nameprep procedure
     can be used.